Okay, last week all of a sudden my external storage hard drive(the kind you insert the HD into a case) decided not to work anymore. I posted a question and got some good information and here is a recap of where I am at:



1. the external HD was showing up in device manager but not my computer or disk management.

2. Someone said it could be the case so I took an old HD out of an old computer and inserted it into the case and it worked as it should: showed up in device manager and my computer and I was able to access it with no problems.



My question is: i have ruled out that the case is not bad. Does that mean all is lost on the bad drive. I had quite a bit of information that I would like to recover if possible. Please help. Thank you. Frank